Problem #PRU-100458

Problems Set theory and logic Mathematical logic Paradoxes

Problem

There were two retired couples Robinsons and Morrises who lived next to each other in a quiet street. They loved animals, especially cats and dogs, but did not consider themselves fit enough to have the actual animals in the house. Instead, they were collecting stamps depicting cats and dogs. Mr Robinson had some stamps with cats and dogs, Mrs Robinson had her own stamps with cats and dogs, and so did Mr and Mrs Morris. It was known that Mrs Robinson had bigger proportion of stamps with cats (the number of stamps with cats to the number of all stamps she owned, i.e. stamps with cats and dogs) than Mrs Morris, and Mr Robinson had bigger proportion of stamps with cats than Mr Morris. Does it mean that the proportion of stamps with cats Mr & Mrs Robinson owned together was larger than proportion of stamps with cats owned by Mr & Mrs Morris?